Skip to content
Business

10 SEO Copywriting Mistakes That Can Hurt Your Website Ranking

By Robert · 5 min read
website copywriting services

A landscaper in Boise spent about $6,000 on a new website last year. Gorgeous thing. Big photos, smooth scrolling, a little falling-leaf animation. It also sat on page four of Google for “landscaping in Boise,” and when he asked me why, it took maybe ten seconds to spot. The homepage never said “landscaping.” Never said “Boise,” either. Just “Crafting Outdoor Dreams Since 1998.”

That’s not a design problem. It’s a words problem, and it’s why a lot of owners in his spot end up looking at copywriting services. Before you hire someone for website copywriting services, though, or start rewriting pages yourself at the kitchen table, it helps to know what usually goes wrong. Here are the ten mistakes I run into most.

Mistakes That Happen Before Anyone Writes a Word

1. Writing in your language instead of your customers’

Dentists say “prophylaxis.” Patients type “teeth cleaning.” Heating and cooling companies love phrases like “climate solutions,” but nobody’s searching that at 11 p.m. in July with a dead air conditioner. They’re typing “AC repair near me.”

Listen to how people describe their problem when they call you. Then write it down exactly like that.

2. Chasing keywords that are way too big

A small insurance office in Tulsa isn’t going to rank for “insurance.” Honestly, nobody is without a giant budget. “Renters insurance for college students in Tulsa,” though? You can win that one. And the person searching it is a lot closer to actually buying.

Mistakes in the Writing Itself

3. Cramming the keyword into every sentence

You’ve seen these. “Our Denver plumbers are the best plumbers in Denver for all your Denver plumbing needs.” Google’s spam policies specifically call out keyword stuffing. Readers can’t stand it either. Use the phrase where it fits naturally, then just talk like a person.

4. Hiding the answer

Somebody searches “how much does a fence cost.” They click your page and get three paragraphs about how your granddad started the business. They’re gone before the second paragraph is over.

Put the answer first, even if it’s only a range. Something like, “Most wood privacy fences around here run between $X and $Y a foot, depending on height.” Then explain the rest. People who get what they came for tend to stick around.

5. Thin service pages

Here’s where I’ll plant my flag: one really good page beats five flimsy ones. Every single time.

So many small business sites have one “Services” page with eight bullet points and two sentences under each. Google can’t tell what you really do. Neither can the customer. If kitchen remodels pay your bills, give them their own page. Talk about cost and timing, what the mess will look like, and the questions people always ask on the first call. A real page. Not a placeholder.

6. Headings that could be on anyone’s site

“Our Solutions.” “Why Choose Us.” You could slap those on a dentist, a law firm, or a dog groomer and nobody would notice. Headings are the first thing skimmers look at, and search engines pay attention to them too. “How Long Does a Kitchen Remodel Take?” actually tells everybody what’s coming.

Mistakes in the Stuff Around the Words

7. Forgetting titles and meta descriptions

Your page title is usually the blue headline people see in Google, and long ones get chopped off, often somewhere around 60 characters. “Home | Smith & Sons LLC” wastes all of it. “Roof Repair in Columbus | Smith & Sons” doesn’t.

Meta descriptions don’t directly change rankings; Google’s said that plainly. They’re still your tiny ad in the search results, though, and a good one gets clicked more.

8. Dead ends

Picture a blog post called “5 Signs Your Water Heater Is Dying” that never once links to your water heater repair page. Somebody reads it, nods along, and closes the tab. Link your pages to each other where it makes sense. It gives readers somewhere to go next, and it helps search engines figure out how your site fits together.

9. Copy-and-paste city pages

This one stings, because people often pay good money for it. A cleaning company wants to show up in twelve suburbs, so somebody writes one page and swaps the town name eleven times. Google treats that pattern as doorway pages, and it can pull the whole site down.

If you really do serve a bunch of towns, each page needs something true about that place, like the neighborhoods you work in or a job you finished there last month. That’s what separates real local SEO services from a find-and-replace job.

The Last Mistake, and When to Pay for Copywriting Services

10. Publishing and walking away

Prices from 2021. A “new this year!” banner that’s three years old. A staff page with someone who quit last spring. Stale copy doesn’t just look sloppy. It slowly loses ground to competitors who keep their pages fresh. Set a reminder to look over your top five pages every six months. For most small businesses, that’s plenty.

Now, the honest bit. You can fix a lot of this yourself. Headings and page titles especially, you could knock out this weekend. And no amount of great writing will rescue a site that crawls on phones or is broken under the hood. That’s a job for web design services or a developer, not a copywriter. Rankings also take time to move, usually weeks or months, so anyone promising page one by Friday is selling you something. If you are weighing agencies, our guide to choosing the right enterprise SEO agency is a useful starting point.

If your site’s been stuck for a while, though, it usually pays to bring in a writer and someone who knows the search side together. Five Talents has both on the same team, which matters more than you’d think. The writers handle website copy and blog articles, and the same team does the search work. When Holy Reads needed help with its app and with getting found online, Five Talents did both. A lot of businesses start by fixing a handful of key pages, maybe with a few hours of SEO consultant services to pick the right ones, and add blog writing services after that.

If your homepage still says something like “Crafting Outdoor Dreams,” it’s probably time for copywriting services that say what you do and where you do it. Visit the Five Talents website and book a free consultation. Bring the page that bugs you the most.